Allegany Co-Op Insurance Company
During Busness Hours - 800-333-1679
After Hours Emergency - 800-501-5787

Chautautua Patrons Insurance Company
During Business Hours - 716-664-5823
After Hours Emergency - 800-501-5787

Erie & Niagara Insurance Association
All Claims - 716-632-5433

Millville Mutual Insurance Company
All Claims - 570-458-5517

National Grange Mutual/Main Street America
All Claims - 877-425-2467

New York Central Mutual
All Claims - 888-234-6926

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
All Claims - 800-333-7642

Progressive Insurance Company
All Claims - 800-274-4499

Allstate Insurance
All Claims - 800-255-7828

Sterling
All Claims - 800-462-4661

Utica National
All Claims - 888-274-1914