Skip to the content
Home > Sue Penhollow

Sue Penhollow

Licensed Agent
Direct: (716) 595-3535

Sue grew up in Cassadaga and resides in Sinclairville with her husband, Bruce. She has two grown children, 8 grandchildren and 5 great-grandchildren. Sue graduated from Cassadaga Valley High School and attended Bryan & Stratton College where she graduated with a degree in accounting.

When Sue began her insurance carrier she attended Fredonia State College and it’s Insurance Agent Program. In 2005 she purchased her own insurance agency in Cassadaga, NY where she has served the community ever since. In the summer of 2026, Sue came onboard with J. Edwards Insurance and is excited about continuing her insurance journey as part of J. Edwards Insurance Agency, Inc.

Insurance products are offered through the following insurers: Erie Insurance (Erie, PA); The Main Street America Group (Jacksonville, FL); The Travelers Indemnity Company (Hartford, CT); Erie And Niagara Insurance (Williamsville, NY); Chautauqua Patrons (Jamestown, NY); Preferred Mutual Insurance (New Berlin, NY); The Progressive Corporation (Mayfield Village, OH); Allegany Co-op Insurance (Cuba, NY); Allstate Insurance (Roanoke, VA); American Modern Insurance (Cincinnati, OH); Conemaugh Valley (Johnstown, PA); Dryden Mutual Insurance Company (Dryden, NY); Foremost Insurance (Carol Stream, IL); The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. (Worcester, MA); J.C. Taylor (Upper Darby, PA); Merchants Insurance Group (Buffalo, NY); Millville Mutual Insurance (Millville, PA); NY State Insurance Fund (Albany, NY); New York Central Mutual (Edmeston, NY); Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company (Bala Cynwyd, PA); Security Mutual Group (Ithaca, NY); ShelterPoint (Great Neck, NY); Sterling Insurance (Boston, MA); The Hartford Insurance Group, Inc. (Hartford, CT); Utica National Insurance Group (New Hartford, NY); Cincinnati Insurance (Fairfield, OH); and other unaffiliated insurers.

Insurance services are provided by an independent insurance agency. J. Edwards Insurance Agency and its producers are licensed in the states where services are offered. License numbers are available upon request. Availability, eligibility, and coverages may vary by state. Not all products are available in all states.